Bestsellers & Brews

Never Lie - Freida McFadden

Discover why Never Lie became a million-copy bestseller despite plot holes that "rival Swiss cheese." McFadden's controversial psychological thriller achieved 23 consecutive weeks on bestseller lists and secured a Netflix adaptation, proving that shocking twists can triumph over narrative logic.
Episode Highlights:
Complete breakdown of the book's journey from self-publishing to Netflix deal
Spoiler-free analysis for potential readers
Deep examination of why the twist both thrills and frustrates readers
Comparison to superior psychological thrillers like "The Boyfriend"
Writer's craft lessons on creating satisfying vs shocking plot twists
Key Timestamp:
14:22 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and twist analysis
Resources Mentioned:
Never Lie by Freida McFadden on Goodreads
Netflix adaptation by Shawn Levy (Deadpool & Wolverine director)
Comparison titles: The Boyfriend, Gone Girl, Diabolique (1955)
BookTok thriller phenomenon analysis
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more psychological thriller breakdowns and hidden gem discoveries.
Join the FREE Skool Community to get good at writing

Foreign Affairs - Alison Lurie

⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: Discussion of suicide, drunk driving fatality, mortality themes
Discover why Foreign Affairs won the 1985 Pulitzer Prize and became a groundbreaking portrayal of middle-aged romance. Alison Lurie's sophisticated comedy of manners follows two American academics in London finding unexpected second chances at life.
Episode Highlights:
Complete breakdown of the novel's prestigious awards (Pulitzer Prize, National Book Award finalist)
Why this pioneering work changed how literature portrays middle-aged women
Spoiler-free recommendation section for potential readers
In-depth analysis of Lurie's narrative techniques and character development
Critical examination of the novel's structural weaknesses and convenience plotting
Constructive suggestions for strengthening character arcs and thematic coherence
Key Timestamp:
25:55 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and detailed analysis
Resources Mentioned:
Foreign Affairs by Alison Lurie on Goodreads
1985 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction
Comparison to Henry James's "The Ambassadors"
David Lodge's campus novels
1993 NBC adaptation starring Joanne Woodward
Trigger Warning: This episode includes discussion of suicidal ideation, drunk driving resulting in death, and mortality themes.
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more Pulitzer Prize winner breakdowns and hidden gem discoveries.
Join the FREE Skool Community to get good at writing

Shield of Sparrows - Devney Perry

Why Shield of Sparrows became the #1 New York Times bestseller that pulled TS back into romantasy after swearing off the genre. This comprehensive review compares Perry's monster-hunting debut against Fourth Wing and Quicksilver to see what works—and what definitely doesn't.
Episode Highlights:
Why this book convinced a reluctant reader to try romantasy again
Complete commercial success breakdown and industry impact
Spoiler-free recommendation: who should and shouldn't read this
Shadow daddy comparison: Guardian vs. Xaden vs. Kingfisher
The Witcher connections and missed monster-hunting opportunities
Character motivation breakdowns that don't make sense
Writing style issues and repetitive middle section problems
Game of Thrones arranged marriage comparison and what went wrong
Key Timestamp:
20:04 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and detailed craft analysis
Resources Mentioned:
Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry (available on Kindle Unlimited)
Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros comparison throughout
Quicksilver by Callie Hart shadow daddy analysis
The Witcher series parallels and monster-hunting concepts
Game of Thrones arranged marriage execution comparison
Red Tower Books publishing strategy discussion
This is TS's third romantasy review on Bestsellers and Brews. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more honest book breakdowns and writing craft discussions.
Next Episode: Foreign Affairs by Alison Lurie
Connect with us: Join the FREE Skool Community to get good at writing: https://www.skool.com/get-good-at-writing

The Lost Bookshop - Evie Woods

⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: Discussion of domestic violence, mental health institutionalization, and infant loss
Discover why The Lost Bookshop became a global phenomenon, selling over 1 million copies in just 11 months. Evie Woods' debut magical realism novel weaves together 1920s Paris and contemporary Dublin through a vanishing bookshop that appears only to those who need it most.
Key Timestamps:
[17:33] - ⚠️ MAJOR SPOILERS BEGIN - Complete story breakdown and analysis
Resources Mentioned:
The Lost Bookshop by Evie Woods on Goodreads
Shortlisted for 2024 British Book Award (Page-Turner of the Year)
Nielsen Gold Bestseller Award 2025
Author's influences: Carlos Ruiz Zafón, Emily Brontë
About This Episode:
This comprehensive review examines both the magical charm and structural flaws of Woods' bestselling debut. We explore how a book about books captured readers worldwide while analyzing specific craft elements that could have elevated it from commercial success to literary masterpiece. Perfect for aspiring writers seeking to understand what makes bestsellers work—and how they could work better.
Trigger Warning: This episode discusses domestic violence, asylum abuse, and infant loss as portrayed in the novel.
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more bestseller breakdowns and writing craft insights.
Next Week: We'll be diving into Shield of Sparrows by Devney Perry!
Connect with us: Join our FREE Skool Community to get good at writing: https://www.skool.com/get-good-at-writing

Project: Hail Mary - Andy Weir

Discover why Project Hail Mary sold over 1 million audiobooks despite critical character flaws. Andy Weir's third novel won the 2022 Audie Award and earned endorsements from Barack Obama and Bill Gates, yet struggles with the same characterization issues that plagued Artemis. This comprehensive review examines why Rocky the alien saves an otherwise flawed narrative.
Episode Highlights:
Project Hail Mary's remarkable commercial success: #1 NYT bestseller, Hugo nominee, Goodreads Choice winner
Spoiler-free analysis of Andy Weir's persistent character development problems
In-depth comparison to The Martian's grounded stakes versus Hail Mary's hypothetical overload
Critical examination of convenient plot devices and missing human conflict
Why Rocky emerges as the book's unexpected emotional core
Film adaptation news: Ryan Gosling stars in the $108 million production (March 2026)
Key Timestamps:
14:44 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot analysis and writing craft discussion
Resources Mentioned:
Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir on Goodreads
2022 Audie Award for Audiobook of the Year
Ray Porter's acclaimed audiobook narration
Comparison to The Martian and Artemis
Brandon Sanderson's review calling it his "favorite book of the year"
✍️ Get Good at Writing - Join the FREE Skool Community: https://www.skool.com/get-good-at-writing
Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more science fiction breakdowns and writing craft analysis.

Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow - Gabrielle Zevin

Discover why Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow became 2022's most celebrated literary phenomenon and #76 on The New York Times' 100 Best Books of the 21st Century. Gabrielle Zevin's acclaimed novel about video game designers Sam and Sadie revolutionized how literature treats gaming culture.
Episode Highlights:
Complete awards breakdown: Goodreads Choice Award, simultaneous #1 Book of Year (Amazon + Time Magazine)
Why this gaming novel sold 2.8 million copies and secured a $2 million film deal
Spoiler-free recommendation section for potential readers
In-depth analysis of Zevin's narrative techniques and character development
Critical examination of friendship dynamics, creative collaboration, and gaming as art
Constructive suggestions for structural improvements and missed storytelling opportunities
Key Timestamp:
17:20 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and detailed literary analysis
Resources Mentioned:
Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin on Goodreads
Goodreads Choice Award for Best Fiction 2022
Film adaptation by Academy Award winner Siân Heder (CODA)
Paramount Pictures and Temple Hill Entertainment production
The New York Times' 100 Best Books of the 21st Century list
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more literary fiction breakdowns and hidden gem discoveries.
Connect with us: Join our FREE Skool community to get good at writing 

Yellowface - R.F. Kuang

Discover why R.F. Kuang's award-winning contemporary satire about literary theft and cultural appropriation became a global phenomenon. This comprehensive review examines whether Yellowface deserves its critical acclaim and commercial success.
Episode Highlights
Complete awards breakdown: Goodreads Choice Award winner, British Book Awards Fiction Book of the Year, and Reese's Book Club selection
Commercial success analysis: #1 New York Times Bestseller with seven consecutive weeks on the list
R.F. Kuang's impressive credentials: Marshall Scholar, Oxford lecturer, and acclaimed fantasy author's first contemporary fiction
Spoiler-free recommendation: Who should read this satirical take on publishing industry tokenism
Deep structural analysis: Character motivation problems and missed psychological thriller opportunities
Controversial industry perspective: Alternative take on "marginalized voices" and commercial storytelling realities
Resources Mentioned
Yellowface by R.F. Kuang on Goodreads
R.F. Kuang's previous works: The Poppy War trilogy, Babel
Comparison titles: Percival Everett's Erasure, Elaine Hsieh Chou's Disorientation
Lionsgate Television adaptation with director Karyn Kusama
Industry context: Publishing diversity initiatives and cultural appropriation cases
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more contemporary fiction breakdowns and hidden gem discoveries.
Connect with us: Join our Facebook book club community

The Dream Hotel - Laila Lalami

Discover why Laila Lalami's genre-bending dystopian thriller The Dream Hotel achieved national bestseller status and Women's Prize for Fiction longlist recognition. The acclaimed author's bold departure from literary fiction explores surveillance capitalism through AI-powered dream analysis and pre-crime detention.
Episode Highlights:
Women's Prize for Fiction 2025 longlist and Read with Jenna Book Club selection analysis
Spoiler-free recommendation section for dystopian fiction and speculative fiction readers
In-depth examination of Lalami's unique background as former computational linguist turned distinguished literary author
Critical analysis of surveillance capitalism themes and algorithmic bias exploration
Comprehensive breakdown of missed storytelling opportunities and character development issues
Key Timestamp:
24:01 - ⚠️ SPOILER SECTION BEGINS - Full plot breakdown and detailed craft analysis
Resources Mentioned:
The Dream Hotel by Laila Lalami on Goodreads
Women's Prize for Fiction 2025 longlist recognition
Read with Jenna Book Club March 2025 selection
Comparison titles: Minority Report, 1984, The Handmaid's Tale
Laila Lalami's previous works: The Moor's Account (Pulitzer finalist), The Other Americans
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis of both acclaimed and disappointing releases. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more dystopian fiction breakdowns, speculative fiction reviews, and hidden gem discoveries in contemporary literature.
Connect with us: Join our Facebook book club community at https://www.facebook.com/groups/4029345297281810

The Silent Patient - Alex Michaelides

⚠️ CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains discussions of suicide and domestic violence.
Discover why The Silent Patient became the #1 New York Times bestseller with over 6.5 million copies sold worldwide. Alex Michaelides' debut psychological thriller won the Goodreads Choice Award and captivated readers globally, but does it live up to the hype?
In this comprehensive review, we break down everything that worked and what didn't in this award-winning psychological thriller. Perfect for book club discussions and readers deciding whether to pick up this polarizing bestseller.
Episode Highlights:
Complete breakdown of The Silent Patient's massive commercial success
Spoiler-free recommendation section for potential readers
In-depth analysis of Alex Michaelides' narrative techniques and writing style
Critical examination of plot devices, character development, and structural issues
Constructive suggestions for story improvement and missed opportunities
Trigger Warning: This episode discusses themes of suicide, domestic violence, and psychological trauma as they appear in the book.
Join our book review community for weekly deep-dive discussions and honest literary analysis. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts for more bestseller breakdowns and hidden gem discoveries. Join our Facebook group

Broken Country - Clare Leslie Hall

Episode Overview
In this episode, TS analyzes Clare Leslie Hall's bestselling novel Broken Country. This deep dive explores what works and what doesn't in this complex tale of a woman torn between two loves in 1960s rural England, while examining how the novel's structure and character development could have been improved.
Key Topics Covered
The premise and dual timeline structure of Broken Country
Character analysis of Beth, Frank, and Gabriel
The love triangle and its execution
The underutilized historical setting of 1960s England
The murder mystery/courtroom drama elements
Beth's problematic character motivations and lack of redemption arc
Craft discussion: missed opportunities and how the novel could have been strengthened
Rural British drink pairing: The Broken Heart Bramble
Timestamps
10:19 - Detailed Spoiler Analysis Begins
Drink Pairing
The Broken Bramble - A sloe gin-based cocktail that captures the rural British setting with its ruby-red color and traditional countryside ingredients, mirroring the bittersweet emotional complexity of the novel.
Non-alcoholic alternative: Countryside Bramble Fizz with blackberry syrup, lemon juice, vanilla extract, and soda water.
Join Our Community!
Be part of our reading community! Join our Facebook group
Next Up
Coming soon: The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides